|Email Newsletters from Pharmaceutical Technology and Pharmaceutical Technology Europe|
Providing the latest business, scientific, and regulatory news for the pharmaceutical and biotech industries.
News from Europe's pharmaceutical manufacturing industry coupled with upcoming events, and exclusive articles and interviews from industry experts.
Solvent-Free Coating of Traditional and User-Friendly Dosage Forms
Tablets and capsules are often coated for various reasons such as to improve their appearance or to make them easier to swallow. Coatings also play an important role in maintaining drug stability, activity, and effectiveness. This article reviews the benefits of solvent-free processes and techniques specifically optimized for coating new dosage forms such as orally disintegrating granules (ODGs).
Coating technologies and methods
In terms of the coating itself, some approaches can lead to structural polymorphism within the coating, which can render it difficult to consistently predict drug-release profiles, bioavailability, and efficacy while also affecting intellectual property (IP) protection and infringement. Such variations can arise during the coating process or develop over prolonged storage; hence, it is important to select a method where these factors have been studied and are well understood.
Liquid coating using solvents
Perhaps the biggest drawback of compression coating is that in the second compression step, it can be difficult to position the tablet core accurately in the center of the tablet, which is important for reproducible formulation and reliable pharmaceutical performance. Various efforts have been made to circumvent this problem, leading to the development of new approaches such as the one-step dry-coated (OSDrC) tablet manufacturing system, which can reduce the likelihood that the compaction process will negatively affect tablet performance (1). The excipients must also be carefully selected. Using appropriate fillers and/or binders is essential to successfully creating a solid dosage form by compression. Finally, because many APIs and excipients are simply not compressible in their crystalline or amorphous forms, an alternative solvent-free coating methodology must be selected.
Electrostatic spray powder coating
For the process to work, however, the coating and tablet core must possess certain conductive properties, or be modified using additional steps to introduce electric charge. To circumvent this issue, the conductivity of the core particle can by increased by wetting it with water to decrease resistance, although this method introduces moisture into the tablet and can lead to instability. Another way to improve conductivity is to modify the surface of the API substrate using polar groups. This method is usually achieved by dissolving the polar groups in a volatile solvent before spraying the solution onto the tablet core, thereby, reintroducing a solvent step into the process. Either way, the electrostatic attraction between the solid substances tends to be weak, hence, making it difficult to produce a thick coat without multiple rounds of spraying and fixing. The fixing step also requires moderate heating, hence, increasing the energy required to carry out the method, which potentially leads to API instability. Current research is focused on finding new ways to increase the conductivity of the tablet core and lower the glass transition temperature of the coating polymer (4).
While coating can proceed rapidly, oxygen in the ambient atmosphere can slow or halt the reaction and in some cases, must be purged from the formulation or manufacturing system using nitrogen, which adds complexity and cost to the process. While this technique has clear applications for heat-sensitive compounds, it is unsuitable for excipients or APIs that are photosensitive. Moreover, the process is expensive and is still in early phase development.
Supercritical liquid coating has so far proven to be effective for coating of fine particles. The supercritical liquid solvating power can be controlled by small changes in temperature or pressure, thereby, enabling the fine-tuning of coating properties (6). However, for the process to work effectively, the core particle onto which the coating forms must be insoluble in the supercritical fluid. In addition, high-pressure equipment is required to carry out the process, which adds further cost to an already expensive approach.
Hot-melt technology for coating ODGs
Orally disintegrating granules (ODGs) are user-friendly dosage forms designed to meet patients’ needs, improve adherence, and increase treatment effectiveness. ODGs provide value for patients as they rapidly dissolve in the mouth, thereby circumventing any issues with swallowing. They can also be quickly and easily administered without the need for water and are much simpler to administer to children and the elderly. As they are not constrained by physical size, ODGs can also be formulated to contain larger amounts of API and/or multiple APIs in a single dose, simplifying treatment regimens.
The effective coating of APIs for ODGs is dependent on many factors. Solvent-based coating is applicable for ODGs, but suffers from heating, drying, and potential stability complications while most organic solvents inherently pose various health and environmental risks. Although several solvent-free approaches have been used with some success for coating ODGs, especially electrostatic spray powder coating, most of them are time-consuming and expensive, often leading to a final product that does not adequately mask the bitter taste of most APIs. In addition, many approaches are not practical for coating large numbers of small granules. For example, compression coating is better suited for coating larger tablets. While new approaches such as supercritical liquid coating and photocuring may offer an effective way to coat ODGs, both methods are still experimental, expensive, and impractical for scale-up.
In an effort to avoid the use of solvents and identify coating methods that might be suitable for ODGs, there has recently been significant research and development into novel methods of pharmaceutical coating. One such technology, hot-melt coating (HMC), is gaining popularity as it offers short processing times (typically under 1 h) and significantly lowers costs compared to other solvent-free methods. HMC avoids the use of solvents by instead utilizing molten mixtures, which are sprayed onto solid particles usually using a fluid bed coating setup. This mixture then solidifies upon cooling to form a protective coating around the seed particle containing the API. The excipients most suitable for HMC include lipids, waxes, fatty bases, and hydrogenated vegetable oils, as they are easy and quick to process, cost-effective, and have relatively low melting points (below 100 °C).
Compared to other solvent-free coating methods, HMC is particularly well suited for taste masking and careful manipulation of API release (8), making it ideal for formulating ODGs. By carefully selecting excipients based on molecular flexibility, hydrophobicity, melting point, molecular weight, and rigidity, as well as optimizing their relative concentrations, it is not only possible to fine-tune the release profile of the API to provide sustained or delayed release but also to provide immediate release products (see Figure 1) (9, 10).
Although HMC can be carried out using a variety of methods and common manufacturing equipment including fluidized bed and spray coating, optimization of the protocol for each API/excipient mixture takes skill, knowledge, and experience. Air-flow, spray rate as well as spray and product temperature must be carefully controlled during the process to enable to successful melting and solidification of the excipient mixture to create a pleasant tasting, homogenous coating with the desired API release characteristics. These parameters are important and when the process is carried out correctly, dosage forms coated using HMC do not suffer from some of the polymorphic variations (and associated challenges) that other coating methods may exhibit.
It is important to create formulation and manufacturing processes that embody quality-by-design (QbD) principles to enable a seamless transition during scale-up, and at the same time employ process analytical technology (PAT) that measure HMC parameters, such as coating thickness, to enable their accurate correlation with final product characteristics. Offline methods, such as scanning electron microscopy, can also be used to assess product quality, because they enable the surface and coating layer of ODGs to be visualized (see Figure 2).
Preliminary results from the ongoing project have highlighted that the production of fast-release medicines using HMC is feasible and amenable to scale-up. The transfer of the technology into production is underway. In several proof-of-principle studies, the parameters for formulating ODGs containing fast-acting APIs were successfully identified. The proof of concept studies included many different lipids, such as mono-, di- and triacylglycerides with varying carbon chain length (C14 to C22). In addition, more than 10 emulsifiers were tested. The resulting dosage forms provide rapid dissolution characteristics, similar to those of film-coated immediate-release tablets. Importantly, the granules are pleasant tasting and easy for patients to ingest. The HMC approach at Hermes is being extended to formulate other fast acting medicines such as ODGs, with the method expected to be fully validated and available for use by pharmaceutical developers in the near future.
About the Authors