Time for a World Tooling Standard - Pharmaceutical Technology

Latest Issue
PharmTech

Latest Issue
PharmTech Europe

Time for a World Tooling Standard
After two centuries, there's no reason to maintain two tablet compression tooling standards.


Pharmaceutical Technology
Volume 3, Issue 32

Tool drawings were also required to perform critical functions related to tablet quality and tablet press operation, including tool inspection procedures and setting limits and controls for punch and die maintenance. The tool drawings also enabled operators to troubleshoot compression and machine problems, such as poor tablet friability, punch binding, and premature tool wear. But most important, the long-term motive of the committee was to publish a tooling standard that governs and softly mandates tablet press and tooling manufacturers to produce equipment in compliance with the American standard. Establishing tooling standards helped to protect the millions of dollars invested in current tooling inventory while maintaining the integrity of established processes and procedures for tool inspection and maintenance. The standards also provided the pharmaceutical industry a uniform price structure useful for budgeting.

Unlike the American TSM standards, the "Euronorm" European standard tool configuration is not published or governed by an organization or association. However, the European tool configuration has been refined and slightly modified from the original Manesty design by European tablet press manufacturers to meet the demand of modern high speed and automated tablet presses.

So today we have two configurations of the world's most common B and D tooling designs; the TSM and the Euronorm. In the past two decades, Europe has dominated the tablet press industry. Therefore, all tablet presses manufactured in Europe for use in the United States must be modified from European design to meet the requirements of the TSM tool configuration. Unfortunately for American tablet manufactures, the Euronorm tool configuration is superior in design and function over the American TSM type. To obtain the peak performance of high-speed tablet presses, serious consideration should be given to modify the original TSM tool configuration to better match that of the Euronorm configuration for which the modern presses have been engineered.

Where do we go from here?

Modifications to the TSM tool configuration are called tooling options and listed in the current TSM Manual. The US is the only country in the world using the original Stokes design, so products being transferred to or from the US may react differently to compression settings and may not be consistent with the original manufacturing site. The two tool configurations are so close to each other that it may be time to consider a world tooling standard. Such a standard would allow consistent tooling and press performance regardless of manufacturing location and interchangeability of tooling between countries. It also would provide a benefit to the tablet press manufacturer who would then be able to produce presses using only one common tool configuration.

Here is a list of the differences between the TSM and Euronorm tool configurations:

  • The TSM punch head configuration has an angled top profile compared with the Euronorm configuration, which uses a domed type head profile. The domed head profile accepts the pressure of the compression roller for tablet compression and reduces the shock and bounce that commonly occurs with the TSM angled profile. Tablet press cams designed for TSM tooling can use the optional domed head design without further modifications to the tablet press or cams and should be considered a standard for all high speed presses.
  • The TSM punch inside head angle for B type punches is 37 compared with the Euronorm, which is 30. The difference between the head angles provides no benefit for either configuration. The inside head angle for the D type configuration however is the same 30 angle for both the TSM and Euronorm type.
  • The overall head thickness is greater in both the B and D configurations for the TSM than for the Euronorm type. Manesty's original theory was that reducing the head thickness would reduce the weight. A lighter punch requires less energy to move vertically through the various compression cycles.
  • The overall punch length of the TSM tool is 0.010 inches shorter than the Euronorm and provides no benefit to either configuration.

The major difference between the two competing tool configurations is the angled head profile of TSM versus the domed head profile of the Euronorm, with the domed head profile being the configuration of choice by the modern, high speed tablet press manufacturers. I see no advantage in maintaining two tooling standards for reasons that cannot truly be justified. Establishing a single punch configuration only makes good sense and will provide overall consistency and efficiency to the pharmaceutical industry.

Dale Natoli is vice-president of Natoli Engineering,


ADVERTISEMENT

blog comments powered by Disqus
LCGC E-mail Newsletters

Subscribe: Click to learn more about the newsletter
| Weekly
| Monthly
|Monthly
| Weekly

Survey
What role should the US government play in the current Ebola outbreak?
Finance development of drugs to treat/prevent disease.
Oversee medical treatment of patients in the US.
Provide treatment for patients globally.
All of the above.
No government involvement in patient treatment or drug development.
Finance development of drugs to treat/prevent disease.
23%
Oversee medical treatment of patients in the US.
14%
Provide treatment for patients globally.
7%
All of the above.
47%
No government involvement in patient treatment or drug development.
9%
Jim Miller Outsourcing Outlook Jim MillerOutside Looking In
Cynthia Challener, PhD Ingredients Insider Cynthia ChallenerAdvances in Large-Scale Heterocyclic Synthesis
Jill Wechsler Regulatory Watch Jill Wechsler New Era for Generic Drugs
Sean Milmo European Regulatory WatchSean MilmoTackling Drug Shortages
New Congress to Tackle Health Reform, Biomedical Innovation, Tax Policy
Combination Products Challenge Biopharma Manufacturers
Seven Steps to Solving Tabletting and Tooling ProblemsStep 1: Clean
Legislators Urge Added Incentives for Ebola Drug Development
FDA Reorganization to Promote Drug Quality
Source: Pharmaceutical Technology,
Click here