Pre-use Filter-Integrity Testing: To Test or Not To Test? - Pharmaceutical Technology

Latest Issue
PharmTech

Latest Issue
PharmTech Europe

Pre-use Filter-Integrity Testing: To Test or Not To Test?
There is no harmonised guidance on pre-use integrity testing of sterilising filters, prompting discussion among users as to whether such testing is necessary.


Pharmaceutical Technology Europe



Jerold Martin
A broad issue for single-use filter users and suppliers across Europe and North America is the pre-use integrity testing of sterilising filters in single-use systems. The subject has received considerable discussion lately, with differences in regulatory requirements and risk assessments being considered. The properties and suitability of gamma-radiation sterilised single-use filtration systems, and the flexibility of these designs, were not considered when regulatory guidelines were written, but now provide additional options for manufacturers. At the moment, there is no harmonised guidance on the pre-use integrity testing of sterilising filters. FDA does not formally require it, stating in its aseptic processing guidance that "Integrity testing of the filter(s) can be performed prior to processing..." (1).

In contrast, the EMA states in EU GMP, Annex 1 that, "The integrity of the sterilised filter should be verified before use..." (2). So, while integrity testing after use is a common requirement, pre-use testing, whether before or after sterilisation, is not a universal requirement. This situation is further complicated in Europe where different national authorities apply EU GMP differently. Some European inspectors demand that pre-use, poststerilisation integrity testing be conducted because it is specifically required in EU GMP, while others are more flexible and do not require it.

The topic was discussed during a workshop at the May 2012 PDA–PIC/S conference in Geneva. Arguments were expressed both for and against testing, but insufficient time was allotted to fully explore the technical issues and no resolution could be drawn. This situation leaves manufacturers with inconsistent international regulatory expectations, and more work is needed to ensure that inspectors have a common understanding.


Hot topics at the IBC Single-Use Applications Conference
The issue is relevant to single-use disposable technology because EMA's published rationale for requiring pre-use, poststerilisation in integrity testing is based on the risks of filter damage or other loss of integrity during high-temperature sterilisation processes, such as steam-in-place or autoclaving.

EMA states, "The filter sterilisation process may be physically stressful for the filter. For example, high temperatures during the process may cause the filter to distort, potentially leading to fluid pathways that allow the passage of particles greater than 0.2 μm in size. The performance of a filter can improve with use, as particles begin to block individual pathways and remove larger pathways that smaller particles could successfully navigate" (3).

Although such filter distortions have been reported for some prototype membranes, commercialised sterilising-grade filters are validated to maintain integrity and not undergo fluid path distortions (enlargement) during steam sterilisation that might enable initial bacterial penetration. Furthermore, sterilisation by gamma irradiation, which is typically applied to single-use filtration systems, can be considered a less stressful process (low heat, low pressure), and has not been implicated in the distortion of fluid pathways or loss of filter integrity so long as the membrane material is compatible with gamma radiation and that gamma dosage does not exceed specified maxima. These parameters are typically certified with every filter or single-use system lot. Many users question whether the possible risk of introducing contamination by performing a pre-use, poststerilisation integrity test on a sterile filter in a gamma-sterilised single-use filtration system is higher than the risk of not performing the test.

The decision on whether or not to perform pre-use integrity testing should be made on a risk-assessment basis. Many users consider the filter manufacturer's integrity test prior to release to be sufficient confirmation that the filter is integral as made and is ready to use upon installation and sterilisation. It is rare for users to experience filter-integrity failures post use, so any user pre-use testing, before or after sterilisation, seems unnecessary. Experience with steam-sterilised filters, however, suggests that most instances of post-use filter-integrity failures, when they do occur, are due to gross filter damage incurred during poorly controlled steam-in-place or occasionally autoclave cycles. Where steaming processes are not well characterised and controlled to avoid filter damage, damage (if it occurs) can be recognised prior to product filtration if a pre-use/poststerilisation integrity test is performed.


ADVERTISEMENT

blog comments powered by Disqus
LCGC E-mail Newsletters

Subscribe: Click to learn more about the newsletter
| Weekly
| Monthly
|Monthly
| Weekly

Survey
What impact do mega-mergers of biopharmaceutical companies have on the development of new drugs?
Improves the quality and number of innovative drugs available to patients.
Restricts innovation and the development of new drugs.
Has no impact on drug development.
Do not know.
Improves the quality and number of innovative drugs available to patients.
29%
Restricts innovation and the development of new drugs.
54%
Has no impact on drug development.
4%
Do not know.
13%
Eric Langer Outsourcing Outlook Eric LangerOutsourcing No Longer Just for Cost-Cutting
Cynthia Challener, PhD Ingredients Insider Cynthia ChallenerSeeking Alternative Catalyst Solutions
Jill Wechsler Regulatory Watch Jill Wechsler Global Expansion Shapes Drug Oversight
Chris Burgess Statistical Solutions Chris BurgessIs a Sample Size of n=6 a Magic Number?
Sean Milmo European Regulatory WatchSean MilmoRegulating the Environmental Impact of Pharmaceuticals
Clusters set to benefit from improved funding climate but IP rights are even more critical
Supplier Audit Program Marks Progress
FDA, Drug Companies Struggle with Compassionate Use Requests
USP Faces New Challenges
Report: Pfizer Makes $101 Billion Offer to AstraZeneca
Source: Pharmaceutical Technology Europe,
Click here