All NewsBio/Pharma News
All PublicationsPharmTechPharmTech Europe
MarketplaceICH Q9 Revision: A Comprehensive Resource on Quality Risk ManagementPeer-Reviewed ResearchPharmTech ProductsPharma InsightsSponsored PodcastsSponsored VideosSponsored eBooksWhitepapers
Webcasts
All VideosAsk the ExpertBehind The HeadlinesBuy, Sell, HoldDrug Digest VideosDrug Solutions PodcastPeer ExchangeSexy ScienceTech Talk
Conference CoverageConference ListingEvents
Subscribe
AnalyticsAnalyticsAnalytics
Data and Artificial Intelligence
Dosage FormsDosage FormsDosage FormsDosage FormsDosage Forms
Drug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug Development
ManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturing
OutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcing
Quality SystemsQuality SystemsQuality SystemsQuality Systems
Spotlight -
  • Analytics
  • Dosage Forms
  • Drug Development
  • Manufacturing
  • Outsourcing
  • Quality Systems
IS1
  • Applied Clinical Trials

  • BioPharm International

  • Cannabis Science and Technology

  • Chromatography Online

  • Nutritional Outlook

  • Pharmaceutical Commerce

  • Pharmaceutical Executive

  • Pharm Tech

  • Spectroscopy Online

  • Turbo Machinery Magazine

AnalyticsAnalyticsAnalytics
Data and Artificial Intelligence
Dosage FormsDosage FormsDosage FormsDosage FormsDosage Forms
Drug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug DevelopmentDrug Development
ManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturingManufacturing
OutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcingOutsourcing
Quality SystemsQuality SystemsQuality SystemsQuality Systems
IS1
  • Applied Clinical Trials

  • BioPharm International

  • Cannabis Science and Technology

  • Chromatography Online

  • Nutritional Outlook

  • Pharmaceutical Commerce

  • Pharmaceutical Executive

  • Pharm Tech

  • Spectroscopy Online

  • Turbo Machinery Magazine

    • Webcasts
    • Subscribe
Advertisement

The Link Between Data Integrity and Quality Culture

October 2, 2018
By Susan J. Schniepp
News
Article
Pharmaceutical TechnologyPharmaceutical Technology-10-02-2018
Volume 42
Issue 10
Pages: 82, 81

Susan Schniepp, executive vice-president of Post-Approval Pharma and Distinguished Fellow, Regulatory Compliance Associates, takes a look at the regulations around data integrity and how they relate to the concept of quality culture.

Q. I have been hearing that regulatory authorities are beginning to audit companies regarding their ‘quality’ culture with relationship to data integrity issues. Can you give me a little background on this issue?

A. The regulatory authorities have always been interested in the culture of an organization. Recently, however, the specific culture of an organization is being connected to the veracity and accuracy of the data generated to support the quality of manufactured products. The theory is the more mature an organization is the more reliable the product support data are. To understand this concept thoroughly, we should start with a brief review of FDA’s quality metrics initiative.

When FDA posted the first draft guidance, Request for Quality Metrics, the metrics chosen were lot acceptance rate, product quality complaint rate, invalidated out-of-specification (OOS) rate, and annual product review or product quality review on time rate. The guidance also contained three optional metrics intended to measure quality culture: measuring senior management engagement, corrective actions and preventive actions (CAPA) effectiveness, and process capability/performance. Although the optional metrics intended to measure quality culture were removed from the current version of the guideline, it is the first indication that regulators felt there was a correlation between culture and data integrity.

At the same time the issue of quality metrics was being discussed, there was a resurgence of data integrity problems in the industry evidenced by the number of citations that reference this issue. Between 2005 and 2016, approximately 225 FDA warning letters were issued with observations for data integrity. These observations included repeat human error deviations, insufficient training, system failures, inappropriate qualification or configuration of systems, poor procedures or not following procedures, and intentional acts of falsification. The increase in data integrity observations prompted regulatory authorities to address the issue by releasing a series of guidelines that reemphasize the importance of data integrity. FDA, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) in the United Kingdom, the World Health Organization (WHO), and the Pharmaceutical Inspection Co-operation Scheme (PIC/S) have all released documents to reeducate the industry on data integrity concepts and expectations (1–5). In addition to the regulatory guidelines, the Parenteral Drug Association (PDA) released a free document titled Elements of a Code of Conduct for Data Integrity to help address the problem (6).

One common theme permeating through these documents is that of quality culture. Regulators have linked the reliability of data to the existence of a quality culture as exemplified by statements taken directly from the guidances. The PIC/S guidance on Good Practices for Data Management and Integrity in Regulated GMP/GDP Environments (5) states, ‘Management should aim to create a work environment (i.e., quality culture) that is transparent and open, one in which personnel are encouraged to freely communicate failures and mistakes. Organizational reporting structure should permit the information flow between personnel at all levels’ (5).

The MHRA guidance (2) titled ‘GXP’ Data Integrity Guidance and Definitions discusses organizational culture, stating, ‘The organization needs to take responsibility for the systems used and the data they generate. The organizational culture should ensure data [are] complete, consistent, and accurate in all its forms (i.e., paper and electronic)’ … ‘The impact of organizational culture, the behavior driven by performance indicators, objectives, and senior management behavior on the success of data governance measures should not be underestimated. The data governance policy (or equivalent) should be endorsed at the highest levels of the organization.’ WHO deals with the concept of quality culture in their document Guidance on Good Data and Record Management Practices (4) by stating, ‘adoption of a quality culture within the company that encourages personnel to be transparent about failures so that management has an accurate understanding of risks and can then provide the necessary resources to achieve expectations and meet data quality standards.’ This same document states, ‘Management, with the support of the quality unit, should establish and maintain a working environment that minimizes the risk of non-compliant records and erroneous records and data. An essential element of the quality culture is the transparent and open reporting of deviations, errors, omissions and aberrant results at all levels of the organization, irrespective of hierarchy.’ Based on the language used in data integrity guidance documents, it is clear that regulatory authorities consider quality culture an important element in establishing the veracity and integrity of the data being generated by companies that support the products they manufacture.

The trouble with quality culture is determining how to measure it. PDA has developed a culture assessment tool that links organizational attributes to specific behaviors (7).

Attributes were defined as elements of a quality system such as, but not limited to, deviations reporting, change control, CAPA, complaints, and environmental monitoring programs or systems. Behaviors were defined as intangibles such as, but not limited to, robust communication and transparency, rewards and recognition, employee engagement, and cross functional vision. The theory was if quality attributes equaled quality behaviors, which then equaled quality culture, then if the quality attributes of a company could be measured, they would reflect the maturity of the quality culture of an organization. The PDA tool involves several steps that include training employees on the use of the tool, an onsite assessment, an all-staff survey, and finally analysis and action on the results. There are, of course, other tools available to measure the culture of an organization. The real point is whatever tool your company uses to measure culture, it will be an important element in determining your data integrity risks and remediating them before an inspection.

Auditing a company to determine if their culture is conducive to generating data that meets the attributable, legible, contemporaneous, original, and accurate (ALCOA) concepts is on the horizon and may become a part of routine audits performed by regulators or industry auditors when evaluating the suitability of a manufacturer, potential partner, or service provider.

References

1. FDA, Data Integrity and Compliance with CGMP Guidance for Industry Draft Guidance (CDER, April 2016).

2. MHRA, A GxP Data Integrity Definitions and Guidance for Industry, Draft version for consultation (MHRA, July 2016).

3. MHRA, GMP Data Integrity Definitions and Guidance for Industry (MHRA, March 2015).

4. WHO, Annex 5, Guidance on Good Data and Record Management Practices (WHO, June 2016).

5. PIC/S, Draft Guidance: Good Practices for Data Management and Integrity in Regulated GMP/GDP Environments (PIC/S, August 2016).

6. PDA, Elements of a Code of Conduct for Data Integrity (PDA, 2015).

7. S. Schniepp, ‘Assessing and Improving Quality Culture: Tool & Resources,’ presentation at 3rd PDA Europe Annual Meeting, June 27, 2018.

Article Details

Pharmaceutical Technology
Vol. 42, No. 10
October 2018
Pages: 82, 81

Citation

When referring to this article, please cite it as S. Schniepp, "The Link Between Data Integrity and Quality Culture," Pharmaceutical Technology 42 (10) 2018.

Download Issue PDF
Articles in this issue

Drug Delivery Innovation Funded by the Gates Foundation
New Dose Forms Focus on the Patient
New Dose Forms Focus on the Patient
Protecting Solid-Dose Shelf Life
Protecting Solid-Dose Shelf Life
Considering Twin-Screw Granulation
Considering Twin-Screw Granulation
Optimizing Containment in OSD Manufacturing
Optimizing Containment in OSD Manufacturing
Sartan Recalls Beg the Question: Is Compendial Impurity Testing Enough?
Sartan Recalls Beg the Question: Is Compendial Impurity Testing Enough?
Developing Lipid-Based Formulations
Developing Lipid-Based Formulations
Efficiency Demands Drive Advances in API Labs
Efficiency Demands Drive Advances in API Labs
AAPS Traces the Path to ICH M10
Outsourcing Development: Small-Scale to Commercial
Outsourcing Development: Small-Scale to Commercial
The Link Between Data Integrity and Quality Culture
Curbing Drug Shortages in Europe
Eq-1.1.gif
Process Stability, Performance, and Capability; What is the Difference?
Lot Release Testing Analytics for Small-Molecule Drugs
Lot Release Testing Analytics for Small-Molecule Drugs
Pharmaceutical Technology North America, October 2018 (PDF)

Newsletter

Get the essential updates shaping the future of pharma manufacturing and compliance—subscribe today to Pharmaceutical Technology and never miss a breakthrough.

Subscribe Now!
Recent Videos
Tore Bergsteiner
Behind the Headlines, Episode 20: CAR-T Milestones, Abbvie and Eli Lilly M&A Moves, and More
DC skyline at night with view of the White House and the Washington Monument | Image Credit: © Jessica - stock.adobe.com
Behind the Headlines, Episode 18
Drug Digest: Patient Preference Drives Solid Dosage Trends
Related Content

Young man having asthma attack or choking suffering from respiration problems | Image Credit: © Feodora - stock.adobe.com

UK Anaphylaxis Nasal Spray Approval Helps Reshape Emergency Allergy Treatment

Christopher Cole
July 18th 2025
Article

Newly approved needle-free adrenaline spray offers longer shelf life, better stability, and easier use, signaling a shift in emergency drug delivery design.


Drug Solutions Podcast: Growth and Advancements in Fill/Finish

Drug Solutions Podcast: Growth and Advancements in Fill/Finish

Felicity Thomas
June 25th 2024
Podcast

In this episode, Hanns-Christian Mahler from ten23 Health chats about the advances in fill/finish.


Kyiv, Ukraine - December 22, 2020: Backlit single shot image of GlaxoSmithKline logo on tv screen with a hand holding an Covid-19 vaccine concept | Image Credit: © Олександр Луценко - stock.adobe.com

FDA Approves Shingrix Prefilled Syringe to Simplify Vaccine Administration

Christopher Cole
July 17th 2025
Article


Drug Solutions Podcast: All About Data: Looking at the EHDS in More Detail

Drug Solutions Podcast: All About Data: Looking at the EHDS in More Detail

Felicity Thomas
May 28th 2024
Podcast

In this episode, Alexander Natz from EUCOPE chats about the European Health Data Space.


ADELAIDE, SOUTH AUSTRALIA. - On November 15, 2018. – The University of South Australia is a public university, it is main campus is located on North Terrace in the Adelaide city centre | Image Credit: © arliftatoz2205 - stock.adobe.com

Why You Should Know About a New Weekly Injectable for Parkinson’s

Christopher Cole
July 15th 2025
Article

Biodegradable weekly implant delivers stable levodopa levels, aiming to streamline Parkinson’s care while reshaping drug reformulation and delivery strategies.


Thornhill, Ontario, Canada - October 31, 2020: LEO Pharma Canada sign outside their head office building in Thornhill, Ontario, Canada. LEO Pharma AS is a multinational Danish pharmaceutical company | Image Credit: © JHVEPhoto - stock.adobe.com.

LEO Pharma Takes Over Global Development of Spevigo for Rare Skin Disease GPP

Christopher Cole
July 14th 2025
Article

The IL-36 inhibitor is being explored for additional inflammatory skin conditions, aiming to expand treatment options for underserved patient groups.

Related Content

Young man having asthma attack or choking suffering from respiration problems | Image Credit: © Feodora - stock.adobe.com

UK Anaphylaxis Nasal Spray Approval Helps Reshape Emergency Allergy Treatment

Christopher Cole
July 18th 2025
Article

Newly approved needle-free adrenaline spray offers longer shelf life, better stability, and easier use, signaling a shift in emergency drug delivery design.


Drug Solutions Podcast: Growth and Advancements in Fill/Finish

Drug Solutions Podcast: Growth and Advancements in Fill/Finish

Felicity Thomas
June 25th 2024
Podcast

In this episode, Hanns-Christian Mahler from ten23 Health chats about the advances in fill/finish.


Kyiv, Ukraine - December 22, 2020: Backlit single shot image of GlaxoSmithKline logo on tv screen with a hand holding an Covid-19 vaccine concept | Image Credit: © Олександр Луценко - stock.adobe.com

FDA Approves Shingrix Prefilled Syringe to Simplify Vaccine Administration

Christopher Cole
July 17th 2025
Article


Drug Solutions Podcast: All About Data: Looking at the EHDS in More Detail

Drug Solutions Podcast: All About Data: Looking at the EHDS in More Detail

Felicity Thomas
May 28th 2024
Podcast

In this episode, Alexander Natz from EUCOPE chats about the European Health Data Space.


ADELAIDE, SOUTH AUSTRALIA. - On November 15, 2018. – The University of South Australia is a public university, it is main campus is located on North Terrace in the Adelaide city centre | Image Credit: © arliftatoz2205 - stock.adobe.com

Why You Should Know About a New Weekly Injectable for Parkinson’s

Christopher Cole
July 15th 2025
Article

Biodegradable weekly implant delivers stable levodopa levels, aiming to streamline Parkinson’s care while reshaping drug reformulation and delivery strategies.


Thornhill, Ontario, Canada - October 31, 2020: LEO Pharma Canada sign outside their head office building in Thornhill, Ontario, Canada. LEO Pharma AS is a multinational Danish pharmaceutical company | Image Credit: © JHVEPhoto - stock.adobe.com.

LEO Pharma Takes Over Global Development of Spevigo for Rare Skin Disease GPP

Christopher Cole
July 14th 2025
Article

The IL-36 inhibitor is being explored for additional inflammatory skin conditions, aiming to expand treatment options for underserved patient groups.

About Us
Advertise
Contact Us
Editorial Info
Editorial Advisory Board
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Privacy Policy
Terms and Conditions
Contact Info

2 Commerce Drive
Cranbury, NJ 08512

609-716-7777

© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.